Falling in love with the very popular thumbprint cookie was easy to do this year. I mean, how do you resist an amazing jam flavor wrapped inside another sweet? I decided the trend should continue on into summer, and am pleased to introduce you today to my favorite new frozen treat – thumbprint popsicles!

You can make the popsicles in so many different flavors, a few of our favorites are noted above. The mixture of frozen pop and textured filling becomes a real treat for a warm summer day.

To make the thumbprint popsicles you will first need to whip up a batch of easy to freeze popsicles; we used chocolate jello, frozen pina colada juice, and mashed strawberries with a bit of honey.

Make your popsicles and insert sticks when semi-hard. Freeze. When ready, remove pops from mold and place heart-shaped cookie cutter on center of one side of a popsicle. Trace the heart shape with a knife and carefully scoop out the center. Fill with marshmallow fluff, preserves, etc. Have fun experimenting and creating frozen treats with a variety of flavor combinations.

Project design and photography by Athena Plichta for A Subtle Revelry. See more sweet treats right here.